Best Submagic Alternative: Why Pay Extra for Basic Clipping?
Love Submagic's captions but hate the extra cost for clipping? Meet the dedicated, affordable alternative. (See how we rank against others in our Best AI Shorts Generators guide.)
Submagic (Submagic.co) is fantastic for adding polished captions to existing shorts. But if you want to turn long videos into shorts, you have to pay for their "Magic Clips" add-on—which costs an extra $19/month per user on top of your subscription.
MakeShorts is the specialized alternative that gives you powerful AI clipping and captions in one affordable package.
Submagic vs. MakeShorts: The Cost Breakdown
| Feature | Submagic (Starter + Magic Clips) | MakeShorts (Plus) | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Price | ~$40/mo (Base + Add-on) | $29.25/mo | 🏆 MakeShorts |
| Yearly Price | High (Base + Add-on) | $9.75/mo | 🏆 MakeShorts |
| Core Function | Captions First | Clipping First | Context Dependent |
| Clip Limits | Unlimited (with add-on) | Unlimited Clips | Tie |
| Complexity | High (Editor-heavy) | Low (Streamlined) | 🏆 MakeShorts |
Why MakeShorts is the Smart Switch
1. Stop Paying Double for One Job
With Submagic, you're paying for a caption tool plus a clipping tool. If your main goal is to find viral moments in long videos, you're overpaying. MakeShorts is built from the ground up to do both: find the clip and add the captions, for one simple price.
2. Streamlined for Repurposing
Submagic is great if you already have a short video and want to spice it up. But if you're starting with a 30-minute YouTube video, MakeShorts is faster. Paste the link, let our AI find the best parts, and export them ready to post. No need to clip manually first or pay extra for the privilege.
3. All-in-One Value
Our Plus Plan ($9.75/mo yearly) gives you generous upload minutes (350 mins/mo) and unlimited clip generation. To get similar functionality from Submagic, you'd be looking at a much higher monthly bill.
Who Should Stick with Submagic?
- Editors: Who already have clips and just need fancy captions.
- Agencies: Who need advanced B-roll libraries and stock footage integration.
Who Should Switch to MakeShorts?
- Podcasters: Who want to automate the "long-to-short" workflow.
- YouTubers: Who need to extract highlights quickly and affordably.
- Budget-Conscious Creators: Who want professional results without the add-on fees.
Ready to Simplify?
Stop paying extra for basic features. Get an AI that does it all.
Ready to create shorts in minutes?
Paste a YouTube link, get social-ready shorts with AI. No editing required.
Try MakeShorts freeNo credit card required • Free credits included